Cake Baking Tips - Common Cake Problems and Cures
External Cake Appearance
| Symptom | Causes |
| Crust too dark |
- Oven too hot. - Excessive top heat. |
| Cake too small |
- Scaling weight too low. - Oven temperature too high. - Batter temperature too high. - Batter temperature too low. - Incorrect amount of water. |
| Cake burned on top |
- Oven temperature too hot. - Incorrect amount of water. |
| Crust is shiny and sticky |
- Oven temperature too cool. - Not baked long enough - Too much sugar in recipe. |
| Crust too thick | - Excessive baking time. |
| Cake falls during baking |
- Excessive jarring or moving of the cake during
baking. - Oven temperature too low. Excessive mixing of the batter. |
| Top of cake peaks and cracks |
- Oven temperature was too hot. (the outside of
the cake baked to form a crust too quickly. As
mixture in center of the cake continued to cook
and rise, it burst up through the top of the
cake.) - Cake wasn't baked on the center rack of the oven. |
| Cake shrinks |
- Excessive liquid. - Batter too cold. - Oven too hot. - Improper mixing procedure. - Baked too long. |
| Cake rose unevenly |
- Flour was not blended sufficiently into the
main mixture. - Temperature inside the oven was uneven. - Oven temperature too high. |
| Cake stuck to the pan |
- Improper greasing/flouring of pan. - Layers were cooled too long before trying to remove them. |
Internal Cake Appearance
| Symptom | Causes |
| Coarse and irregular grain |
- Improper mixing procedures. - Stiff batter. - Careless or poor depositing in the pans. - Oven too cool, (baked too slowly). |
| Dense grain |
- Excessive liquid in the batter. - Improper mixing procedure. |
| Off-color cakes |
- Improper mixing procedure. - Oven too cool, (baked too slowly). - Unclean equipment. |
| If raisins, nuts or dried fruit sunk to the bottom |
- Pieces of fruit were too large and too heavy. - Sugary syrup on the outside of the fruit was not washed off- causing the pieces of fruit to slide through the mixture as it heated. - Washed and dried fruit was not dusted with flour before being added to the mixture. - Cake mixture was over beaten or was too wet so it could not hold the fruit in place. - Oven temperature was too low, causing the mixture to melt before it set to hold the fruit in place. |
General Cake Faults
| Symptom | Causes |
| Batter over-flowed the pans |
- Wrong adjustments to recipes (too much liquid,
flour etc.) - Wrong size pan used. Mixture should fill 2/3 of pan. |
| Poor flavor |
- Improper mixing procedure. - Improper cleaning and greasing of the pans. - Faulty baking conditions. - Improper cleaning of the equipment. |
| Cakes too tough |
- Excessive mixing. - Batter too stiff (insufficient water). - Batter too thin (excessive water). |
| Lacks body/structure |
- Excessive mixing - Insufficient liquid. |
| Dries out too soon |
- Excessive baking time. - Insufficient liquid. - Improper mixing procedures. - Cooled in a drafty location. |
Baking Hints for Cakes
| Symptom | Causes |
| Baking |
- Set your ovens about 20 minutes before baking.
Use an oven thermometer to test the temperature
inside. - When you use a spray release agent on your cake pans, be sure the spray contains flour, or if it doesn’t, light dust your own flour over the sprayed pan. - Bake cakes at 350 to 360 degrees in regular oven. - Bake cakes at 330 to 335 degrees in convection oven. - Handle the cakes carefully when removing from the oven. - Place cakes on the center rack in the middle of the oven. - Pans should not touch the sides of the oven. - If your oven bakes unevenly on one side, do not pick up the pan, but rotate it about 2/3 into the baking time. - Make sure the batter is level in the pans. - Cakes will spring back when touched, when they are done. The sides will shrink slightly away from the pan and a cake tester or toothpick inserted into the center comes out clean. - Baking times will vary with pan size and batter weight. |
| Mixing |
- Batter temperature should be 70 to 75 degrees. - ALL equipment should be clean and grease free. - Make sure your measuring cups and spoons actually hold the same volume if you are using them from different sets. - Measure all ingredients as accurately as possible. - Pans should be greased properly. - When using a stand-up kitten mixer, use a paddle (not a wire whip) to mix the batter. - Use a rubber or soft plastic spatula to scrape the sides of the mixing bowl after each addition of ingredients. (Scraping ensures proper ingredient distribution.) - Follow the formula exactly as to mixing times. - Always use fresh, high quality ingredients. - Follow the formula exactly as to method. Use precise mixing times. If not, disaster may result! |
| Handling |
- Cool cake in pan 10-15 minutes before
loosening the edge and turning it onto a wire
rack. Hint: To easily remove a cake form the pan, place a double thickness paper towel over the wire rack. The towel prevents the wire bars from breaking the crust or leaving imprints on the top of the cake - Turn hot cakes out gently. - Cool cake at least 1 hour before decorating. Hint: When frosting a cake, chill the cake before spreading filling and/or frosting. (Cake will be much easier to work with.) Also, apply a thin layer of frosting to the cake and then refrigerate until it is set before applying the final, heavier layer of frosting. This will seal in the crumbs and ensure a clean final appearance. - Make only enough to last 3 or 4 days. |
